Some very bright students just do not do well with standardized tests like the ACT or SAT. Often, they do not bother to apply to prestigious schools because their test scores are too low. No clear connection between high SAT or ACT scores and future academic success has been proven. Consequently, more than 800 colleges and universities across the nation are adopting a “test-optional” policy. Students may apply without a SAT or ACT score. The goal is to attract a more diverse pool of students.
It is not surprising that the College Board (the organization that prepares and administers standardized tests) defends the use of SAT and ACT scores for college admission. They maintain that the scores on these tests are the best predictors of college success. However a study shows that the best predictors of student success in college are high school grades. Students who did not submit SAT or ACT test scores did just as well as those who did submit.
Critics of standardized admission tests argue that these tests are primarily used by influential schools as sorting tools to filter thousands of college applications. Most likely the ACT and SAT will not go away soon. But as more high-profile schools adopt a “test-optional” policy, they are acknowledging that high-achieving students, who are not necessarily good with standardized tests, should not be excluded from admission.